The Sword of the Sea review scores are in, and critics are absolutely loving what Giant Squid has created. This atmospheric adventure game has earned an impressive 88 on Metacritic, with several publications awarding perfect scores. But what exactly makes this surfing adventure so special?
What Critics Are Saying About Sword of the Sea
The critical reception has been overwhelmingly positive, with reviewers praising everything from the stunning visuals to the fluid movement mechanics. Here’s what major gaming publications think:
| Publication | Score | Key Takeaway |
|---|---|---|
| DualShockers | 10/10 | “Profoundly impressed me, one of the standout titles of 2025” |
| PlayStation LifeStyle | 10/10 | “One of the PS5’s best games” |
| Push Square | 9/10 | “Natural progression of Journey’s legacy” |
| COGconnected | 90/100 | “Ideal choice for impactful gaming experience” |
| The Indie Informer | 9/10 | “Beauty uplifted my spirit” |
The Giant Squid Magic Behind Sword of the Sea
Giant Squid, the studio behind beloved titles like Abzu and The Pathless, has crafted another atmospheric masterpiece. The team’s signature style shines through in every aspect of the game, from the stunning environmental storytelling to the fluid traversal mechanics.
What sets this game apart is how it blends the studio’s previous experiences. Critics note it combines the environmental beauty of Journey, the fauna elements of Abzu, and introduces fresh surfing mechanics that feel incredibly satisfying.
Gameplay That Flows Like Water
The core gameplay revolves around riding your Hoversword through breathtaking landscapes. Critics consistently praise the movement mechanics, with PC Gamer noting how “fluid movement elevates it beyond its basic puzzles.” The game draws inspiration from skateboarding titles, creating a unique surfing experience across desert dunes and ancient ruins.
Players take on the role of the Wraith, exploring a world that needs to be brought back to life. The traversal feels effortless and joyful, which several reviewers highlighted as the game’s strongest element.
Visual Splendor That Critics Can’t Stop Praising
Nearly every Sword of the Sea review mentions the game’s spectacular visuals. GamesRadar+ specifically praised how “the distinctions between air, water, and land are wonderfully blurred,” creating an immersive experience that feels both dreamlike and grounded.
The art direction clearly draws from the team’s work on Journey, but critics note it establishes its own unique identity. The golden sand dunes, submerged ruins, and diverse landscapes create a world that begs to be explored.
Short But Sweet: The Perfect Length Debate
One consistent theme across reviews is the game’s length – approximately three hours from start to finish. TheGamer’s reviewer called it “an incredibly enjoyable three hours,” while others noted that the brevity actually works in the game’s favor.
However, not all critics agreed on this point. Slant Magazine felt the game “concludes rather abruptly” and that “something essential is missing.” Most reviewers, though, appreciated the focused experience that doesn’t overstay its welcome.
Available on PS Plus: Perfect Timing
The game’s inclusion in PS Plus Extra from launch has been universally praised by critics and players alike. This accessibility means more people can experience what VDGMS called “a heartfelt tribute to nature and the connection we forge through it.”
Why Critics Think You Should Play
The overwhelming consensus among reviewers is that Sword of the Sea offers something unique in today’s gaming landscape. It’s a game that prioritizes emotional experience over mechanical complexity, creating what The Indie Informer described as “hope amidst despair.”
Critics consistently mention how the game made them feel – uplifted, peaceful, and connected to something larger. In an industry often focused on competitive multiplayer and complex systems, this meditative adventure stands out as something special.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Sword of the Sea worth playing if I didn’t like Journey?
Critics suggest yes – while it shares DNA with Journey, it has its own identity with unique surfing mechanics and different pacing. The gameplay is more active than Journey’s walking simulator elements.
How long does it take to complete Sword of the Sea?
Most reviewers completed the game in approximately 3-4 hours. Critics note this feels like the perfect length for the experience.
Do I need PS Plus to play Sword of the Sea?
No, while it’s available on PS Plus Extra, you can purchase it separately on PS5 and PC. Critics recommend it regardless of how you access it.
What makes the movement in Sword of the Sea special?
Critics praise the fluid surfing mechanics that blend skateboarding inspiration with the studio’s signature graceful movement. The Hoversword traversal feels both satisfying and meditative.
Is Sword of the Sea suitable for all ages?
Yes, critics note it follows Giant Squid’s tradition of creating beautiful, non-violent experiences appropriate for both children and adults.
How does Sword of the Sea compare to other Giant Squid games?
Critics see it as a natural evolution, combining the best elements of Abzu and The Pathless while establishing its own unique identity through the surfing mechanics.
Conclusion
The Sword of the Sea review consensus is clear: Giant Squid has created another masterpiece that prioritizes beauty, emotion, and joyful movement. While some critics wished for a longer experience, the overwhelming majority praise it as a standout title that reminds us why video games can be art.
With an 88 Metacritic score and multiple perfect scores from major publications, this atmospheric adventure proves that games don’t need complex mechanics to create profound experiences. Whether you’re a fan of the studio’s previous work or new to their style, critics unanimously recommend diving into this beautiful world.